4 Actors Who Turned Down Iconic Villain Roles

Billy Bob Thornton turned down the Green Goblin — Willem Dafoe took the mask

Thornton was offered the Green Goblin in 2002's Spider-Man but said he "just can't be in makeup that long" and wasn't interested in playing a villain. Willem Dafoe took the role instead, delivering one of the most memorable comic-book performances of the era.

John Lithgow passed on The Fly's tragic monster — Jeff Goldblum became Seth Brundle

Lithgow was first offered the role of scientist-turned-monster Seth Brundle in The Fly, but said he found the story "such an icky story" and didn't want to play something so grotesque. Jeff Goldblum took the role, delivering a performance now considered one of body horror's finest.

Toshiro Mifune turned down Darth Vader over fears it would hurt his image

According to his daughter, legendary samurai-film star Toshiro Mifune was George Lucas's first choice for Darth Vader, but turned it down out of skepticism toward sci-fi and concern it would undermine his tough-warrior image. The role went to David Prowse in the suit, with James Earl Jones providing the now-iconic voice.

David Warner did makeup tests as Freddy Krueger — then dropped out for a scheduling conflict

Warner was originally cast as Freddy Krueger and had already gone through makeup tests for A Nightmare on Elm Street before a scheduling conflict forced him to drop out at the last minute. Robert Englund took over the role and played Krueger in nearly every subsequent film in the franchise.